GaN vs SiC in Power Electronics: What’s the Difference?

The main difference between GaN vs SiC lies in their material properties and applications. GaN switches faster and can be made smaller, which benefits high-frequency electronics like power supplies and data centers. On the other hand, SiC can handle higher voltages and heat more effectively, making it ideal for electric vehicles and renewable energy systems. Market data shows both GaN and SiC are growing rapidly, with medium power devices being the most widely used. The Asia-Pacific region is the fastest growing market.

Aspect	Details
Market CAGR (2023-2030)	About 27.3%
Market Size by 2030	Over 5.7 billion US dollars
Fastest Growing Segment	Medium power devices (CAGR over 28% from 2024-2032)
Leading Region by Revenue (2022)	North America (338.97 million US dollars)
Fastest Growing Region	Asia-Pacific (CAGR about 27.6%)

Choosing between GaN vs SiC depends on your specific needs. Some applications require high-frequency, compact electronics, while others demand high-power, reliable devices. Engineers and designers consider factors like cost, reliability, and system compatibility when making their choice.

Key Takeaways

• Gallium nitride (GaN) switches on and off very fast. It works well in high-frequency, medium-voltage electronics. People use it in fast chargers and data centers. This makes devices smaller and more efficient.

• Silicon carbide (SiC) can handle higher voltages and more heat. It is great for high-power things like electric vehicles. It also works well in renewable energy systems. SiC is very reliable.

• GaN gives high switching speeds and strong power density. But it needs good cooling to work well. SiC manages heat better and lasts longer in hard places.

• You pick GaN or SiC based on what you need. Think about voltage, frequency, power, cost, and reliability. GaN is good for medium voltage and speed. SiC is better for high voltage and power.

• Both GaN and SiC cost more than silicon. But they work better and are more efficient. New technology is trying to make them cheaper and easier to make.

Material Basics

Gallium Nitride

Gallium nitride is a special wide bandgap semiconductor. It is used in many modern power electronics. This material helps make high-frequency devices work well. Engineers use gallium nitride in gan transistors. They also use it in high electron mobility transistor designs. The bandgap of gallium nitride is between 3.4 and 3.6 eV. This is higher than most older semiconductor materials. Because of this, gan can handle higher voltages. It also switches faster than other materials. Gallium nitride resists electric breakdown very well. This makes it good for small and efficient mosfet devices. But gallium nitride has thermal conductivity of about 1.3 W/cmK. This is lower than silicon carbide. So, gallium nitride mosfet devices need careful cooling in high-power uses. Many designers pick gallium nitride when they want fast and small devices.

Silicon Carbide

Silicon carbide is another wide bandgap semiconductor. It is popular for high-power and hot environments. The bandgap of silicon carbide is between 2.2 and 3.3 eV. The exact value depends on its crystal structure. This bandgap is a bit lower than gallium nitride. But silicon carbide is better at moving heat. Its thermal conductivity is about 5 W/cmK. Silicon carbide mosfet devices can handle more heat. This makes sic transistors great for electric cars and factories. They are also used in renewable energy systems. Silicon carbide mosfet devices last long and work well in tough places. Many engineers choose silicon carbide for strong and reliable performance.

Wide Bandgap Comparison

Wide bandgap semiconductors like gallium nitride and silicon carbide are changing power electronics. Both materials are better than old silicon in voltage, speed, and efficiency. The table below shows their main properties:

Material	Bandgap Range (eV)	Thermal Conductivity (W/cmK)
Gallium Nitride	3.4 - 3.6	1.3
Silicon Carbide	2.2 - 3.3	5

Gallium nitride’s higher bandgap means it switches faster. It also handles higher voltages. This helps gan mosfet and gan transistors work better. Silicon carbide’s high thermal conductivity helps sic mosfet and sic transistors stay cool. Both materials are important for wide-bandgap devices. Their strengths fit different needs. Engineers compare these semiconductors to pick the best mosfet material for each job.

Note: Wide bandgap semiconductors help make devices smaller, more powerful, and more efficient than old silicon mosfet technology.

Electrical Performance

Switching Speed

Switching speed is very important in power electronics. Gan mosfet devices switch much faster than silicon or silicon carbide. Gan uses special transistors that let electrons move quickly. This makes switching speeds reach about 100 V/ns. Gan mosfet devices can work at MHz frequencies. This fast speed helps power supplies get smaller and more efficient. But engineers need to watch out for electromagnetic interference at these speeds. Silicon carbide mosfet devices also switch faster than old silicon. But they are not as fast as gan. Sic mosfet devices give up some speed for better power and heat control. Both gallium nitride and silicon carbide help modern power systems work better.

• Gan transistors work at MHz frequencies. They are great for small, efficient power supplies.

• Sic transistors switch faster than silicon. They focus more on handling power and heat.

Voltage Ratings

Voltage rating tells how much voltage a device can safely handle. Gallium nitride mosfet devices work best from 300V to 900V. They are good for high-frequency and medium-power uses. Fast chargers and data centers use them. Silicon carbide mosfet devices are best for high-voltage power supplies. Sic can handle voltages from 1.7 kV to 3.3 kV or more. This makes sic the top pick for electric vehicles and renewable energy systems. The table below shows typical voltage ratings:

Device Type	Typical Voltage Rating	Example Product	Application Focus
Gan	Up to ~900V	PI 900V Gan products	Medium power, high frequency
Sic	1.7 kV to 3.3 kV+	Wolfspeed 3.3 kV Sic modules	High-voltage power supplies, EVs, renewables

Silicon carbide’s strong material lets it work well at high voltages and temperatures. Gallium nitride is still the best for fast, medium-voltage switching.

Power Density

Power density shows how much power fits in a small space. Gan mosfet devices allow high power density by switching very fast. For example, gan can reach about 3.8 kW/L in electric vehicle chargers. In small USB-C chargers, gan can get up to 42 W/in³. This makes gallium nitride great for small, powerful devices. Silicon carbide mosfet devices also reach high power density. They do this in high-voltage uses. Sic can get about 4 kW/L in single-phase chargers. It can reach up to 10 kW/L in advanced EV chargers. Both gallium nitride and silicon carbide help engineers make smaller and better power systems.

Note: High power density means devices are smaller, lighter, and more efficient for users.

gan vs sic in Applications

High-Frequency Uses

Gallium nitride is great for high-frequency power jobs. It lets electrons move fast and switches quickly. Gan devices can work at MHz frequencies. This helps in RF circuits, satellite links, and wireless charging. Gan is also used in fast chargers and data center power systems. These jobs need small and efficient designs with lots of power in little space. Gan switches fast and loses less energy than silicon carbide here. Experts say gan is best for very high-frequency power converters, especially near 650 V. Gan lets engineers put power parts together on one chip. This makes it perfect for high-frequency power changes.

High-Power Uses

Silicon carbide is best for high-power jobs. Sic devices handle high voltages and big currents better than gan. Many industries use silicon carbide for power in data centers, electric cars, and green energy inverters. Sic also makes home heat pumps smaller and more efficient. High-current and high-power designs work better with sic modules. These modules protect circuits faster than old electromechanical parts. Silicon carbide works well in tough places like factories, trains, and car electrical systems. Sic can work at high heat and has strong thermal performance. This makes it the top choice for high-power uses.

• Common high-power uses for silicon carbide:

  • Data centers

  • Electric vehicles

  • Renewable energy inverters

  • Home heat pumps

  • Circuit protection in car electrical systems

Efficiency

Efficiency is important in all power jobs. Both gan and sic are better than old silicon devices. In high-voltage and high-power inverters, silicon carbide can reach up to 99% efficiency. This helps electric cars go farther and use smaller batteries. Sic devices are 5-10% more efficient than silicon in these jobs. Gallium nitride is best for medium voltages, especially at 650 V. Gan gives great efficiency at light loads and switches very fast. This makes gan good for data centers and car power systems. The table below shows how they compare in inverter jobs:

Parameter/Aspect	SiC Devices	GaN Devices
Typical Voltage Range	Above 900 V	300-900 V
Efficiency in Solar Inverters	Up to 99%	Great light load efficiency at 650 V
Efficiency Improvement	5-10% better than silicon	Best light load efficiency
Application Focus	High-voltage, high-power inverters	High-frequency, medium-voltage inverters
Switching Frequency	Lower than GaN, made for high power	Very high (MHz range)
Thermal Performance	Great, easy cooling	Good, not as ready for high voltage
Market Adoption	Leads in EV and solar inverters	Growing in data centers and car power
Cost	More than silicon	Less because of Si base

Note: Silicon carbide leads in high-power inverter markets. Gallium nitride is best for high-frequency, medium-voltage, and efficient jobs.

Cost Factors

Manufacturing

Making GaN and SiC devices costs a lot. GaN devices need special ways to be made, like HVPE and MBE. These ways use fancy machines and skilled workers. SiC devices also need advanced steps, but these are now more common. Factories make more SiC devices now, so prices drop. Both types need careful work because they handle high power. They must also meet strict quality rules.

Substrate Costs

Substrate costs are a big part of the price for GaN and SiC devices.

• GaN substrates cost a lot. A two-inch GaN substrate can be about $1,900 or more.

• Silicon substrates are much cheaper. They cost $25 to $50 for a six-inch wafer.

• GaN substrates are pricey because of raw materials and hard ways to make them.

• GaN-on-SiC substrates cost about 50% more than SiC-on-SiC ones. This makes GaN grow slower in the market.

• SiC substrates can be half the total device price. New SiC substrates help lower costs by making more devices from one wafer.

• The SiC substrate market is growing fast. Bigger wafer sizes help cut costs even more.

Note: GaN substrates cost a lot. This makes it hard to use them everywhere, especially where price matters.

Scalability

Scalability means how fast companies can make more GaN and SiC devices.

1. GaN substrates are small, usually four inches or less. They have many defects and grow slowly, so making more is hard.

2. GaN devices also have problems with doping and gate oxide. These can cause breakdowns in high-power jobs.

3. SiC substrates are stronger, but they still cost a lot. Packaging is also hard, especially for power MOSFETs.

4. Both GaN and SiC need special packaging. They handle high power and voltage.

5. Not having a worldwide supply chain and world issues can slow both down.

Tip: As tech gets better, GaN and SiC may get easier and cheaper to make for power electronics.

Reliability

Gate-Oxide Reliability

Gate-oxide reliability is important for how long power devices last. Gallium nitride and silicon carbide each have their own problems. The table below lists the main problems and fixes for each:

Device Type	Common Gate-Oxide Reliability Issues	Key Mechanisms and Effects	Mitigation Approaches
SiC MOSFETs	High density of defect states at SiO2/SiC interface causing bias-temperature instability (BTI) and threshold voltage (Vth) shifts	Electron trapping at interface defects; higher electric fields due to thinner gate oxide (e.g., 40 nm vs 100 nm in silicon) exacerbate effects; extrinsic defects cause variability and larger Vth shifts	Nitridation of gate oxide to reduce interface states; screening extrinsic defects; thicker gate oxides in trench MOSFETs to reduce failure rates; understanding bipolar AC gate stress effects
GaN HEMTs	Charge trapping at AlGaN/GaN interface and dielectric layers causing dynamic on-state resistance degradation and current collapse	Electron injection under positive drain-gate bias leads to trapped negative charge reducing 2DEG density; impact ionization at high positive gate bias injects electrons into gate dielectric (silicon nitride), generating holes and net positive charge, increasing electric fields and causing positive feedback; gate overvoltage and leakage at p-GaN depletion layer cause reliability issues	Control of gate voltage to avoid overvoltage; packaging to reduce parasitic inductance; understanding and managing impact ionization effects; device design to minimize leakage and percolation paths

Engineers use special steps to make gate-oxide more reliable. For silicon carbide, they use nitridation and thicker oxides to stop failures. For gallium nitride, they control the gate voltage and use smart packaging to lower breakdown risk.

Thermal Management

Thermal management is very important for both gallium nitride and silicon carbide. This is true in high-power and hot jobs. GaN devices are small and work well with heat. They need advanced printed circuit board designs. Engineers use six-sided cooling and thermal layers to move heat away. They also use sidewall cooling to help with heat. For GaN, the focus is on the PCB and packaging. Careful copper trace layout and signal routing help heat escape.

Silicon carbide works at higher heat and power. It needs strong packages and good heatsinks for enough thermal mass. Engineers use special die-attach methods like sintering to help with heat and electricity. Old package styles can limit silicon carbide. New designs use surface-mount technology and special thermal materials. Both types need careful modeling and testing. The big difference is GaN uses PCB cooling, while silicon carbide uses package heat sinking.

Tip: Good thermal management helps devices last longer and work better, even in tough places.

Device Longevity

Device longevity means how long a power device works before it fails. GaN transistors last a long time, often over 25 years if used right. Studies show GaN devices keep failure rates very low, even with voltage spikes—less than one part per million. Data from cars and satellites show almost no gate failures.

Silicon carbide devices are also very reliable. They work well in high-power and hot jobs. This makes them great for electric cars and green energy systems. Both gallium nitride and silicon carbide do better with careful design and testing. This helps them meet the needs of hard jobs.

Selection Guide

gan transistors vs sic transistors

Engineers look at gan transistors and sic transistors for power electronics. Gan transistors use gallium nitride. Sic transistors use silicon carbide. Both are wide bandgap semiconductors. Gan transistors work best at medium voltages from 300V to 900V. They switch very fast, up to 1MHz. This makes gan good for high-frequency power supplies and fast chargers. Data centers also use gan transistors. Gan helps make power systems smaller and more efficient.

Sic transistors handle higher voltages, above 900V. They work well in high-power jobs like electric cars and solar inverters. Silicon carbide gives sic strong heat control and high breakdown voltage. These features help sic work in hot and tough places. Sic transistors last longer and need less cooling in big jobs.

The table below shows how gan, sic, and silicon compare:

Selection Criterion	GaN Transistors	SiC Transistors	Silicon (for context)
Voltage Range	Medium voltage (300-900V)	High voltage (above 900V)	Low voltage (below 300V)
Switching Frequency	High frequency (100kHz - 1MHz)	Moderate frequency, optimized for power	Low frequency (under 100kHz)
Cost	2-3x silicon cost, moderate premium	3-5x silicon cost, higher premium	Lowest cost, widely available
Efficiency & Power Density	Excels at high switching speeds, enabling smaller, more efficient designs	Superior thermal conductivity and power handling for high power applications	Adequate for low power, cost-sensitive uses
Typical Applications	Fast chargers, data center power supplies, medium voltage power supplies	Electric vehicle powertrains, renewable energy inverters, industrial drives	Basic motor drives, low-cost adapters
Technical Considerations	Requires complex gate drive (negative voltage turn-off), advanced packaging	Requires careful gate driver isolation, advanced thermal management	Mature, simpler design and packaging
System-Level Benefits	Smaller size, higher efficiency, reduced cooling needs	Higher efficiency at high voltage, reduced losses, longer system life	Cost-effective but less efficient at high voltage/frequency

Tip: Gan transistors are best for high-frequency, medium-voltage jobs. Sic transistors are great for high-power and high-voltage uses.

Application Suitability

Application needs help pick between gan and sic devices. Engineers check power level, switching speed, temperature, efficiency, size, and cost. Gan works well in high-frequency, medium-voltage jobs. These include small solar inverters and data centers. Gan makes power supplies smaller and more efficient.

Sic is best for high-power jobs. It handles higher voltages and works in hot places. Electric cars, big solar inverters, and motor drives use sic. Silicon carbide gives sic strong efficiency and heat control. Sic solar inverters reach over 99% efficiency. This makes sic perfect for large green energy systems.

Cost matters too. Sic costs more than silicon but saves money by needing less cooling and using energy better. Gan costs less than sic but more than silicon. Gan is picked for high-frequency and small designs. Design problems like gate drive and heat control also matter.

• Voltage: below 300V, silicon works; 300-900V, gan is best; above 900V, sic wins.

• Frequency: under 100kHz, silicon is good; 100kHz-1MHz, gan leads.

• Cost: silicon fits cheap jobs; gan and sic are for better performance.

• Sic is key for 800V electric car powertrains, helping batteries last longer.

• Gan is used in data centers for high efficiency and small power delivery.

• Sic solar inverters reach over 99% efficiency.

• Gan and sic have trade-offs like higher cost, tricky gate drive, and heat control.

• The choice depends on voltage, speed, power, heat, and cost for each job.

Note: Picking gan or sic depends on what each power job needs.

Decision Table

This table helps engineers compare gan and sic for different jobs. It lists important facts and shows which device fits best.

Parameter/Aspect	GaN Devices	SiC Devices
Bandgap Width (eV)	3.4	3.26
Breakdown Field (MV/cm)	3.3	3.0
Electron Mobility (cm²/Vs)	2000	900
Thermal Conductivity (W/mK)	130	490
Voltage Range	300-900V	Above 900V
Switching Frequency	100kHz - 1MHz	Up to 100kHz
Power Density	High	Very High
Efficiency	Best at high frequency	Best at high voltage
Reliability	Long life, low failure rate	Long life, strong in harsh environments
Scalability	Growing, benefits from silicon infrastructure	Growing, driven by wafer size and substrate innovation
Typical Applications	Data centers, fast chargers, medium voltage inverters	EV powertrains, solar inverters, industrial drives

Engineers should check reliability data before picking a device. Both gan and sic need careful design for gate drive and heat control.

Cost is important too. Sic costs more because of expensive materials and hard manufacturing. Gan has lower material costs and simpler designs, so prices may drop as tech gets better. Scalability depends on wafer size and new materials for both gan and sic.

• Gan grows faster because it uses silicon and current factories.

• Sic grows with bigger wafers and new materials.

• Both need more investment in making and training workers to grow faster.

Picking gan or sic depends on voltage, speed, power, heat, cost, reliability, and how easy it is to make for each job.

GaN and SiC are both important in electronics. GaN switches faster and is good for small, high-frequency designs. SiC works best in places with high voltage and tough conditions. Engineers pick the right device for each job. They think about how well it works, how much it costs, how long it lasts, and how easy it is to make more. The table below shows the main differences:

Aspect	GaN	SiC
Best For	High-frequency electronics	High-voltage electronics
Efficiency	Superior at MHz speeds	Superior at high voltages
Reliability	Long life, low failure	Rugged, proven in industry

If you want to learn more, check trusted journals. The Journal of Crystal Growth and Applied Physics Letters have good research on these power electronics technologies.

FAQ

What is the main difference between GaN and SiC?

Gallium nitride switches very fast. It is good for high-frequency jobs. Silicon carbide can handle more voltage and heat. Engineers pick GaN when they want speed and small size. They choose SiC for strong power and lasting devices.

Where do engineers use GaN devices most often?

Engineers use GaN in fast chargers and data centers. They also use GaN in small power supplies. These jobs need quick switching and small designs. GaN helps make electronics smaller and work better.

Tip: GaN is best for medium-voltage and high-frequency uses.

Why do electric vehicles use SiC devices?

Electric cars need parts that handle lots of voltage and heat. SiC works well with heat and lasts a long time. SiC helps cars go farther and save energy.

Benefit	SiC in EVs
High Voltage	✅
Heat Resistance	✅
Long Life	✅

Are GaN and SiC more expensive than silicon?

Yes, GaN and SiC cost more than silicon. GaN is cheaper than SiC. Engineers pay extra for better speed and strong devices. Prices may go down as factories get better.

 

 

 

 

 

Written by Jack Elliott from AIChipLink.

 

AIChipLink, one of the fastest-growing global independent electronic   components distributors in the world, offers millions of products from thousands of manufacturers, and many of our in-stock parts is available to ship same day.

 

We mainly source and distribute integrated circuit (IC) products of brands such as Broadcom, Microchip, Texas Instruments, Infineon, NXP, Analog Devices, Qualcomm, Intel, etc., which are widely used in communication & network, telecom, industrial control, new energy and automotive electronics. 

 

Empowered by AI, Linked to the Future. Get started on AIChipLink.com and submit your RFQ online today!